The Best Ice Cream Sandwiches In New York City

Macaron Ice Cream Sandwiches
François Payard Bakery

It’s that time of year again! National Ice Cream Sandwich Day is Tuesday, August 2, and before the celebration begins, we wanted to give you the inside scoop on which local eateries have the best treats for you and your sweet tooth this summer. So cool off on a hot summer day and enjoy this special holiday with any and all of the following deliciously unique ice cream sandwich creations!

Big Gay Ice Cream: Visit the Big Gay Ice Cream Shop located in both the West Village and the East Village for a scrumptious selection of Melt Sandwiches! Try on for size the newest and greatest BGIC exclusive sandwich called the Rue McClanahan (smooshed together with a combination of Praline Pecan Cookies and Bourbon Ice Cream) and be sure to come by repeatedly as the menu is always changing with a rotating season selection! biggayicecream.com

Carpe Donut: Here’s yet another incredibly delicious and creative ice cream sandwich concoction, this one straight from Carpe Donut NYC. You’ve never eaten a donut like the ones they’ve got at Carpe Donut, let alone infused with ice cream! Enjoy freshly made donuts with the cool sensation of rich ice cream, but act fast because Carpe Donut’s menu is always changing. Check out their website for more, including other fun donut creations! carpedonutnyc.com

Coolhaus:
If you haven’t tried one of Coolhaus’ famous Sammies, then now’s the time! Prepackaged to perfection, these ice cream sandwiches come in a wide variety of tasty concoctions that are sure to satisfy your taste buds. From more traditional flavors like Cookies and Cream and Mint Chip, to the more distinctive, like Peanut Butter and Candied Bacon, Coolhaus’ menu is jam packed and has the perfect flavor for everyone! eatcoolhaus.com

François Payard Bakery: Chef François Payard is back this year and his signature ice cream sandwiches are better than ever! Try one of the Payard’s many gourmet creations, including Strawberry Cheesecake, Pistachio Rasberry, and Salted Caramel, all squished together between two delicious macaron shells! With locations in Columbus Circle, the Plaza Food Hall, Murray Street, and Houston Street, there’s always a Payard ice cream sandwich near you, and it’s calling you name! fpbnyc.com

[gravityform id=”13″ title=”false” description=”false” ajax=”true”]

The Good Batch: Can’t control your ice cream sandwich cravings? Head over to the Good Batch Bakery in Clinton Hill, Brooklyn, and get your fix! Always infused with a creamy center of Blue Marble Vanilla ice cream, take you pick from a variety of sandwiches, like the original Goodwich (made with signature sea salt sprinkled Oat Chocolate Chunk cookies) or the Birthday Cake (with rainbow confetti sugar cookies). Can’t get enough? The Good Batch offers a humongous sampling tray, including each and every offered ice cream sandwich flavor that is sure to satisfy even your biggest dessert desires. thegoodbatch.com

Mikey Likes It Ice Cream: Ice cream sandwich…with waffles… enough said! At Mikey Likes It, not only can you enjoy an incredible ice cream sandwich, high atop several pieces of waffles, but you also get to pick your choice of flavor for your delectable ice cream and your waffle! It doesn’t get much better than this, folks. mikeylikesiticecream.com

Belgian Waffle Ice Cream Sandwich
Neuhaus Chocolate

Melt Bakery: Open since the summer of 2010, Melt Bakery has been a staple in New York City desserts for many years and counting–especially when it comes to the ice cream sandwich game. Their ice cream sandwich flavors include Red Velvet Meltcakes with Cream Cheese Ice Cream, Snickerdoodles with Cinnamon Ice Cream, and of course the Classic, Chocolate Chip Walnut with Vanilla Ice Cream. Head down to Little Italy to get yours! For more, visit Melt Bakery’s website to see a complete list of flavors and to order online! meltbakery.com

Neuhaus Chocolate: Neuhaus was already a standard-bearer in the world of NYC sweet treats, but their Belgian Waffle Ice Cream sandwich really takes things to a new level–especially with National Ice Cream Sandwich day on the horizon. Drizzled with rich melted chocolate and sprinkled with chopped nuts, Neuhaus’ delicious ice cream treats are the perfect dessert on a hot summer day. neuhauschocolate.com

Odd Fellows Ice Cream Co.: Ice cream sandwiches at Odd Fellows (with locations in Williamsburg and in Manhattan) are one of a kind! Go the traditional route and taste one of their Signature Sandwiches, layered in crunchy and gooey toppings, or try an “OddPocket,” a warmed up version of an ice cream sandwich that’s been heated under a Panini press! Better yet, and if you can’t make up your mind, indulge in your own ice cream sandwich creation, a DIY invention, where you get the opportunity to choose your own toppings and cookie! You can take a trip to Odd Fellows – The Sandwich Shop in the East Village if you’re in search of only ice cream sandwiches and nothing else! oddfellowsnyc.com

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Relevant Directory Listings

See More

Gaga Madness

<p><span style="font-size: 10pt; font-family: Arial;" data-sheets-value="{" data-sheets-userformat="{">Gaga is the hottest new sport in NYC. We've taken the fun of GAGA and pushed it into overdrive. Energetic coaches, pumped up music, sideline commentary, gear giveaways and more. Stay active and keep fit with this new craze that's sweeping the city.</span></p>

Adventuring Portal

<p><a name="m_-1473885667065203258__Hlk72147528"></a>Adventuring Portal runs Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) games for kids.   We have created a safe online space for tweens and teens to learn and play D&D.</p> <p>Our D&D Summer Camp session are a one-week experience.  Monday – Friday.  Each day will be 3 hours of gaming (with 2 breaks build in).  15 total gaming hours for $180.  If you have played with us before, you are entitled to 10% off.   </p> <p>Need your kids, nieces or nephews, grand kids or neighbor’s kids to be occupied for a bit so you can get work done & take care of your to-do list? Maybe your tween or teen is still a bit isolated and craves connection with their peers? Whether your teen/tween has played D&D before or is brand-new to the experience, this safe space brings players together to have fun and solve problems as a team in ways few other online opportunities do.</p> <p>All our games focus on experiential learning.   Our players leave knowing all the basic game play as well as experiencing: teamwork, bravery, compassion, generosity, negotiation, improvisation, gamer etiquette, strategy, critical thinking, problem solving, cartography and probability - all through online D&D adventuring!</p> <p>We are an inclusive organization and welcome gamers who are LGBTQIA+ and those on any spectrum. </p> <p>All girls’ groups available. </p> <p>I am a parent, a certified elementary school and middle school math teacher and last summer in the midst of the mess started Adventuring Portal, an online Dungeons & Dragons business for kids. There are so many benefits to playing D&D and I hope you will consider us as a great way for your child to safely socialize, grow as people and have a great time.</p>

Asphalt Green

<p><span style="font-size: 10pt; font-family: Arial;" data-sheets-value="{" data-sheets-userformat="{">Asphalt Green’s high-quality sports programs start at 4 months old. Two beautiful facilities in vibrant Manhattan neighborhoods provide the optimal space for children to learn the fundamentals, play for leisure, or compete at the highest level.<br />As the leading sports and fitness facility in Manhattan, Asphalt Green’s never-before- seen training methods focus on improving your mental and physical game. Whether participating in swim, soccer, flag football, martial arts, basketball, baseball, tennis, or volleyball, coaches instill values that set athletes up for success in life and bring out their full potential in sports.</span></p>