The Facts About Mixing Fish With Pregnancy And Nursing

Stephanie Clarke
Stephanie Clarke

Parents-to-be and new parents are flooded with decisions to make. What to eat or not eat, where to deliver the baby, which gear to register for––it’s exciting and overwhelming all at once. And when it comes to eating, how to navigate the waters around eating seafood has been a confusing issue.

As a registered dietitian and new mom, questions about consuming seafood during pregnancy and nursing are some of the most common food questions I get. Fortunately, as long-term research studies have emerged, I’m happy to say that recommendations have never been more clear and convincing. If you’re pregnant or nursing, it’s likely that you should be eating more fish for the health of your baby. And with the exception of four very large, and very uncommon, fish to avoid (shark, tilefish, king mackerel, and swordfish), don’t worry so much about which fish to eat. Just. Eat. More. Here’s why:

We’re not eating the recommended amounts: The US Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA) research estimates that most women simply aren’t eating enough fish to maximize health benefits to baby. In fact, their research shows that pregnant women are only eating an average of 1/2 serving of fish per week. One serving is 3-4 oz, or about the size of a woman’s palm. The FDA’s draft recommendation is to get at least 8-12 oz per week, or 2-3 servings.

Seafood is a superfood for healthy moms and babies: I’m not usually a proponent of labeling “superfoods,” since it’s the combination of foods in a healthful diet that gives the biggest health benefit. However, if I had to choose one food to dub a “superfood,” fish would be at the very top of that list.

Fish is a great source of lean protein and iron, two nutrients particularly important during pregnancy. It’s also rich in many other vitamins and minerals including vitamins A & D, selenium, choline, and iodine. What sets fish apart even further, making it so important during pregnancy and lactation, is that it’s the predominant dietary source of omega-3 fatty acids, specifically DHA, which is an essential and key nutrient in the development of a fetus’s brain and nervous system.

Moms need 200 mg/day of DHA to cover both their needs and baby’s. You can get that in 2-3 servings of fatty fish per week. Some of the best sources of omega-3 DHA include fatty fish such as salmon, tuna, sardines, herring, anchovies, and bluefish. Almost all fish contain some DHA, so no matter which ones you enjoy, you’re getting a benefit. Eating a variety and making sure to include fatty fish will ensure that you’re getting enough omega-3.

The benefits greatly outweigh the risks: What about mercury concerns? This has been a sticking point and the reason why so many women shy away from fish during pregnancy. It’s understandable too, as mixed messages may have you thinking that you’d be doing something that could potentially harm your child. However, research shows us that the opposite is true. In more than 110 studies that the FDA reviewed for their new guidelines, the evidence shows that the net benefit of eating seafood, traces of mercury and all, is overwhelmingly positive, and that avoiding it is detrimental to baby’s health. In these studies, women who ate the recommended amount of seafood each week had babies with IQs an average of three points higher than those who had not eaten fish. That’s pretty powerful stuff.

In this report, they even assessed individual types of fish and their average mercury content to establish how much of that fish you would need to eat to have a negative impact. This showed that even canned albacore tuna, which under the current FDA advice has a recommended limit of 6 oz per week, can be consumed in amounts up to 67 oz per week before you would see an adverse effect on baby. Based on this research, the new 2015 Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee report is recommending that this old albacore-limiting advice be revised. Again, it all comes back to eating more seafood and the fact that it’s not only safe, but advisable, to do so.

Start simple: If preparing or eating more fish in general seems overwhelming, start with something simple and convenient. Canned and frozen fish are nutritious and easy to incorporate into meals. I’m a big fan of adding canned tuna or salmon to salads, whole wheat pasta, tacos, whole grain dishes, and casseroles, like a tuna enchilada casserole, for an easy lunch or dinner. If you’re not preparing as much fish at home, make it a point to order fish when you dine out.

To learn more about Bumble Bee Seafoods, visit bumblebee.com!

Stephanie Clarke is a registered dietitian, nutritionist and co-owner of C&J Nutrition, an NYC- and Washington, DC-based nutrition communications, consulting, and workplace wellness company. She is also a contributing nutrition expert for SELF magazine and a consultant for Bumble Bee Seafoods. Stephanie holds a Master of Science degree in Nutrition Communications from Tufts Friedman School of Nutrition Science and Policy. She lives in the DC area with her husband, 10-month-old daughter, and cat. 

Relevant Directory Listings

See More

Ghostlight Theater Camp

<p>Ghostlight Theater Camp is a summer theater camp for campers ages 9-17. Providing 10-day, 3-week, and 6-week programs that combine high-caliber theater training with a traditional summer camp experience. </p> <p>Working with Broadway artists both in classes and in productions, campers will have access to skill development, mentorships, and lifelong connections that will follow them beyond camp. Ghostlight focuses on ensemble theatre values and practicies that support individuality and self-expression in the context of community. This means that no camper at Ghostlight is in the back row or sitting on the side. Each day brings multiple opportunities to perform and create with fellow campers in an environment filled with support. </p> <p>When not making theater, campers can enjoy the benefits of a summer camp in Maine that no other theater camp offers. Stargazing in a hammock, walks in the woods, downtime by the pool, and quiet time reading in the Gazebos with the sound of wind all around are some of highlights of a summer unplugged and away from screens. </p> <p>Finally, the most meaningful and lasting gift of a summer at Ghostlight is the friendships made that last a lifetime. Though the love of theater brings us together, and the work we do stands out from other experiences, the community focus of Ghostlight Theater Camp is why we hear, year after year, that campers cannot wait to return. </p>

OASIS DAY CAMP CENTRAL PARK – Manhattan

<p class="MsoNormal"><strong>Give Your Child A Lifetime of Memories At A Beautiful Summer Oasis</strong></p> <p><strong> </strong></p> <p class="MsoNormal"><strong>25 AMAZING SUMMERS, LIFELONG FRIENDS!</strong></p> <p class="MsoNormal">Unparalleled quality summer camp at the ICONIC Central Park in the heart of New York City. Over 90 activities for kids 3-16 Sports, Swim, Enrichment, + Teen Travel.<span style="mso-spacerun: yes;">  </span>Warm Social and Emotional Environment. As part of the Oasis family, kids gain confidence, compassion, self-esteem & individuality.</p> <p class="MsoNormal">Oasis Day Camp offers specialized programming for campers 3 – 15 years old. A traditional day camp in every way, Oasis prides itself on quality programming at parent-friendly prices. Oasis has swim, sports, art, music, dance, nature, and enrichment programming as well as air-conditioned indoor facilities, and the great outdoor green shady fields and athletic facilities! There are trips for teens and, the most well trained, caring staff in the industry. Daily hot lunch and snacks and transportation options.</p> <p class="MsoNormal">Oasis gives campers the opportunity to be active, think creatively, and discover new friendships that will last a lifetime. Truly a summer to experience the outdoors and a traditional camp right in your neighborhood.</p>

Laurissa Jane Music

<p>Laurissa Jane Music Studio is a dedicated institution that offers a solid foundation for students to explore the captivating world of music and arts. With experienced instructors, we offer private and group lessons in piano, voice, and guitar, for all ages and skill levels. We provide year-round training for renowned programs such as NYSSMA (New York State School Music Association) and ABRSM (Associated Board of the Royal Schools of Music). LJMS runs an annual Summer Musical Theatre Arts Program from July-August which offers a creative environment for young individuals with a passion for acting, singing, and dancing. We are proud to serve the vibrant communities of Jamaica Queens and can also provide classes virtually. At LJMS, we firmly believe in the transformative power of the arts. Call us today!</p>