You don’t have to be an interfaith family to celebrate both Hanukkah and Christmas each year. Any family can choose to celebrate whichever holiday traditions they wish. Holiday joy can be doubled, rather than halved, when you choose to light the menorah and decorate the Christmas tree to honor the cultural and religious traditions of both parents.
So forget the “December Dilemma.” When it comes to religion, families increasingly run the Judeo-Christian gamut. In our family, we have Orthodox Jews on one side of the family tree and born-again Christians on the other side. But my husband and I both share the same beliefs about diversity, tolerance, and spirituality. And that’s what we intend to pass on to our daughter.
As a woman who was raised Catholic and has been happily married to a Jewish man for the past 13 years, I can attest that once you become a parent in an interfaith family, you quickly become accustomed to not being able to please everyone. But since the wisdom of your hearts brought you and your partner together in the first place, why not call on that same source of wisdom to guide you through creating your own version of happy holidays?
Here are a few tips based on what our family has learned from holding the middle ground over the years:
Talk to each other first and last
The bottom line on family celebrations, holiday or otherwise, is to always do whatever you and your spouse deem best for your family. The only way to come to an understanding about what this means is to discuss it with each other first and last.
Be prepared for this to be an ongoing conversation, and probably one that you revisit each year.
Protect your joint point of view
Never let bossy or opinionated family members horn in on conversations that rightly belong between you and your partner. You only have one spouse, and that’s the person whose opinion you should value most. Your kids come next, and the grandparents after them.
Don’t treat your parents like children or allow them to treat you like a child. This behavior will only create conflicts between you and your spouse.
Ignore disapproving outsiders
Never apologize for being an interfaith family, even if people in your extended family or circle of close friends do not approve of your union. You are not seeking their permission — as Perchick expressed so boldly in “Fiddler On The Roof” — you are asking for their blessing.
Creating harmonious and joyful dual holidays in your own home is your parental right and your familial duty, even if it means agreeing to disagree with certain members of your extended family.
Stick to separate but equal
Christmas may be more common and commercial than Hanukkah, but don’t let that trump your holiday fun. The nice thing about Hanukkah is that it lasts for eight nights. Light the menorah candles and say the Hanukkah prayer every night, if you possibly can. You may be amazed at how moving and inspiring such simple rituals can be, even on busy school nights.
Look for the quieter, more awe-inspiring moments in Christmas as well, such as ending the day admiring the beauty of the decorated tree and window lights.
Keep both sets of traditions
At our house, we celebrate as much of both traditions as we can, without a worry about whether the holidays overlap or not. For me, this means the Christmas tree, the presents, the cookies, the big dinner. For my husband this means lighting two menorahs for eight nights (one for him and one for my daughter), having our daughter’s friends over for potato latkes, and some lively dreidel games.
Don’t double your gift budget
We make an effort to celebrate the bounty of two holidays without going overboard. If you are an interfaith family, your kids’ friends may consider them “lucky” because they assume that they get double the gifts every holiday season. However, that’s not necessarily the case at our house.
Our daughter typically gets a little present on the first day of Hanukkah and a bigger present on the last day of Hanukkah. One set of grandparents send a couple of little Hanukkah gifts and a check and the other sends a couple of stocking stuffers and a check. The amount of gifts she receives is essentially the same as it would be if we only celebrated one holiday.
Share the love
Another thing we enjoy about dual holidays is that our daughter can share traditions about both holidays with her friends, no matter what religion they follow, exposing them to a culture they may not have had the opportunity to learn about.
Participate wisely
When invited to join a new or old tradition on either side of the family, give the ritual a chance. We will try just about anything once. But we reserve the right to say “no” to pressure or anything that makes us uncomfortable.
Maintaining an atmosphere where you can say “yes” or “no” to your parents without stern chastisement may not come easily in your extended family system. But start trying it, or you’ll never get there.
Honor the choices of others
We don’t try to protect our family members from our choices. They need to be exposed to what we value, if we expect them to understand and accept our choices. However, we also try to respect the choices that each of our family members make without imposing our life choices on them. The Jewish families get Happy Hanukkah cards and the Christian families get Christmas cards. When we cross over, we go with “Happy Holidays.”
Author, journalist, and writing coach Christina Katz loves celebrating the winter holidays with her family and friends. Each year her family enjoys exchanging ornaments for the tree and inviting a new group of friends over to play the dreidel game and enjoy potato latkes.
Fun holiday family reads
Hanukkah:
“Hanukkah!” by Roni Schotter and Marilyn Hafner
“Lots Of Latkes, A Hanukkah Story” by Sandy Lanton and Vicki Jo Redenbaugh
“When Mindy Saved Hanukkah” by Eric Kimmel
“It’s A Miracle! A Hanukkah Storybook” by Stephanie Spinner and Jill McElmurry
Christmas:
“The Christmas Story” by Jane Werner Watson and Eloise Wilkin
“‘Twas The Night Before Christmas or Account Of A Visit From St. Nicholas” by Clement Clarke Moore
“How The Grinch Stole Christmas” by Dr. Seuss
“The Polar Express” by Chris Van Allsburg
Celebrating both:
“My Two Holidays, A Hanukkah and Christmas Story” by Danielle Novack and Phyllis Harris
“Light The Lights, A Story About Celebrating Hanukkah And Christmas” by Margaret Moorman
“Daddy Christmas and Hanukkah Mama” by Selina Alko
