New York Estate Of Mind

What inspired you to write this book?
I’ve always found the giant apartment buildings on Central Park West to be particularly beautiful; they hold real mystery for me. One time I went to visit my friend Susan who was staying with her aunt, who lived in one of those apartments, so I got to go up there and see it. It was a day that I held in my heart for a long time—the privilege of getting to be inside one of those apartments and poke around and hear about the history of the building. That was 10 years ago, so I’ve been sitting on that for a long time and wondering what it would turn into, and it finally appeared as a novel.

Did you have any real estate experiences in your personal life that are similar to those in the book?
The story about losing your inheritance happened to my brother’s wife. Her father remarried late in life and he deeded everything over to his wife. So [ultimately] everything she owned, her entire history was suddenly owned by someone else. My husband and I have had several buying and selling experiences in New York, and they never are simple. What I find interesting is how complicated things can get without warning. We live in a brownstone house in Brooklyn now. The guy who lived here had been trying to renovate it by hand for 30 years, and the place looked like a complete wreck. He was living in one room of this brownstone that was collapsing around him. Everybody told us we would never get him out, but he fell in love with my husband and he felt like he was a worthy heir for this house. So he moved on and we got this place, but I will never forget that craziness of walking into what looked like a respectable brownstone and wandering into this insane other world. I think these places are more mysterious than we give them credit for—we see things through this kind of prism of order and real estate and what things are worth.

A lot of the familial relationships in the book seem damaged or unhappy. Why did you choose to portray the characters in this way?
They’re broken people because Tina [the main character] is broken in the same way. She has to heal herself by healing other people. She has to learn about her own brokenness, which is related to the loss of her family, by mending that wound in other people in the building. It’s a fairytale structure on some level. That’s the hero’s journey, to discover himself by healing others.

The whole story is about a fight between two families over an apartment, yet you end the story unresolved. Why?
I think that grasping at ownership is not the way to own something. Tina didn’t need that place, she needed to find her own place and she needed to find herself.

What do you think families can take away from this story?
Certainly I feel like this story is about claiming family as your identity rather than claiming wealth or place. Everyone is wounded because they’ve lost a sense of family on some level.
In the end, Tina finally finds herself in a marriage and having a child. So I would say that it celebrates family as the root of the soul.

What made you switch from writing plays to writing novels?
I’d always been curious about it, honestly. I’d fantasized about it for a long time and wanted to try it.

What are some differences you’ve noticed between the two genres?
Once you’ve finished a play, moving it into the world—like finding a director, finding a theater, negotiating production—is enormously complicated and wearing on the spirit. For a play you need a whole lot of other people for the thing itself to exist as it’s meant to exist in the world. You don’t have to go through any of that with fiction because the thing itself is its own fulfillment. All you need to do is keep working on it until it achieves its own perfection. At one point I said to my husband, “You know, I could fall out of a tree and write a play before I hit the ground.” I’ve been a playwright for almost 20 years now and I’ve only been a novelist for six, so I still see myself as an apprentice as a fiction writer. It’s very complicated, it’s a form with a lot of traps, and I’m still negotiating and learning those traps. One thing I prefer about fiction is that the politics are much simpler. You’re just by yourself writing this world.

You live with your husband and children in Brooklyn. What do you like to do in the city with your family?
I take my kids to the theater a lot because I’m a TONY voter, so I have to see everything on Broadway, but it’s more fun if I go with one of my kids. I went to go see The Addams Family, and I enjoyed it so much more because my daughter thought it was hilarious. It was really great to watch it with her. My son gets engaged in the theater in completely different and original ways and that’s fun for me too.